Bitcoin News
The history of Bitcoin’s 2017 blocksize war and Bitcoin Cash

Scaling Debates and Satoshi’s Limit
Satoshi Nakamoto added the 1MB block size limit in September 2010 through hidden commits that introduced the MAX_BLOCK_SIZE variable. Before this addition, blocks were technically bound by a soft cap of 500 to 750kb. In October 2010, developer Jeff Garzik proposed a 7MB block size on a BitcoinTalk.org thread to match the transaction rate of PayPal. Satoshi responded by warning Garzik that such an increase would make him incompatible with the network.
The scalability debate resurfaced in 2013 as services like Silk Road and Satoshi Dice increased on-chain transaction volume. By 2014, transaction fees increased as the number of on-chain transactions nearly doubled. In July 2015, Jeff Garzik proposed BIP100, which allowed miners to vote for a block size between 1MB and 32MB. Under this system, a 75% miner supermajority must vote for an increase, and no increase can exceed 5% of the size of the previous block. Gavin Andresen proposed BIP101, which would increase the block size to 8MB through an algorithmic schedule that doubles every two years.
The community divided into three interest groups: miner maximalists, enterprise maximalists, and hard-fork minimalists. Mike Hearn and Gavin Andresen launched Bitcoin XT in 2015 to implement BIP101. However, the Bitcoin XT network suffered a massive Distributed Denial of Service attack in December 2015 that prevented nodes from communicating for weeks.
The 2017 Conflicts and the BCH Fork
The 2017 New York Agreement proposed activating SegWit followed by a SegWit2x hard fork to reach a 2MB block size, a move intended to follow the February 2016 meeting known as the Hong Kong Agreement where miners requested a 2MB increase as a condition for SegWit. This plan faced opposition from those who believed it gave too much power to a small number of companies. SegWit achieved activation in the summer of 2017 through a user-activated soft fork, but the 2MB hard fork failed. Roger Ver, the CEO of Bitcoin.com, led a movement to reject SegWit and support Bitcoin ABC. He attracted supporters including Bitmain to push for a chain split.
Bitcoin Cash (BCH) forked from Bitcoin on August 1, 2017. Because only a minority of miners moved to the new chain, Bitcoin ABC used the Emergency Difficulty Adjustment (EDA) algorithm to manage the drop in hashrate. The first Bitcoin Cash block was mined 6 hours after Bitcoin Block 478558 by ViaBCT, a Chinese mining pool and exchange.
| Feature | Bitcoin (BTC) | Bitcoin Cash (BCH) |
|---|---|---|
| Block Size Limit | 1MB | Larger than 1MB |
| Max Supply | 21 Million | 21 Million |
| Consensus | Proof-of-Work | Proof-of-Work |
| Primary Use Case | Store-of-Value | Peer-to-Peer Payments |
The Technical Divide Between ABC and SV
Bitcoin Cash focuses on low-fee, high-throughput transactions for peer-to-peer payments. It retains the 21 million coin cap and the proof-of-work mechanism from its parent chain. In November 2018, the network split again when parties failed to reach consensus on a single direction. This created Bitcoin ABC (BCHABC) and Bitcoin SV (BCHSV). Bitcoin ABC implemented Canonical Transaction Ordering (CTOR), which helps miners by reducing the time spent figuring out payment order by 70%. Opponents of CTOR in the BCHSV camp argued the technology remained untested and could increase network risk.
BCHABC developers claim CTOR allows for parallel validation and easier block encoding. They also argue it eliminates certain classes of attacks by fraud miners. Conversely, BCHSV supporters, including those linked to Craig Wright, want to restore several old OP-codes from the original 2009 Bitcoin protocol. This move aims to make the network closer to version 0.1.0. The hashrate for BCHSV is supported by CoinGeek, which is sponsored by billionaire Calvin Ayre.
You should understand how these technical differences create lasting divides between developers. Roger Ver directed the mining operations of his Bitcoin.com pool to ABC. Bitmain also publicly supported ABC during the hash wars, even renting hash power and deploying 90,000 of its own mining rigs to favor ABC operations. Jihan Wu allegedly unloaded BTC to fund the ABC mining operations, which drove prices of crypto down.
Lawsuits and the Arrest of Roger Ver
United American Corp (UAC) filed a lawsuit in the Southern District of Florida against Bitmain, Jihan Wu, Roger Ver, and others. The lawsuit alleges that the group colluded to stage a premeditated hostile takeover of the BCH network during the November 2018 hash war. UAC claims the resulting centralization violates decentralized protocols established since Bitcoin’s inception. The court rejected a request by the defendants to dismiss the case with prejudice in early 2020. The block size war clearly exposed the deep philosophical fractures within the cryptocurrency community.
The legal battle involves accusations of fraud and market manipulation. UAC asserts that Bitcoin ABC introduced arbitrary checkpoints that allow the group to take over the network. Bitmain and Ver’s camp argue that implementing checkpoints in the BCH software code merely increased competition and created two separate chains. Kraken, an exchange led by Jesse Powell, also faces scrutiny because it was among the first to declare that ABC offered the "true version" of BCH.
Roger Ver, known as "Bitcoin Jesus," faced arrest in Spain for tax fraud. The US Department of Justice alleges he defrauded the US of over $48 million by concealing the value of his Bitcoin holdings. He allegedly used several companies to transfer ownership of his assets to evade an exit tax when renouncing his US citizenship. Does the legal pressure on prominent figures eventually change how decentralized networks operate?
| BCH Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Current Price | ~$360 – $420 |
| Market Cap | ~$7.3 – $9.3 Billion |
| Circulating Supply | ~20 Million |
| Max Supply | 21 Million |