Bitcoin News
Bitcoin’s stock-to-flow model reliability: five myths vs facts

Scarcity provides a reliable framework
The S2F model effectively quantifies scarcity. PlanB, a pseudonymous Dutch investor, created this framework in March 2019 to compare a commodity’s existing stock against its annual production. This ratio indicates how many years of production it takes to reach the current supply. Gold maintains a stock-to-flow ratio of approximately 62. The World Gold Council pegs the total gold stock at 190,000 tons. Annual gold production ranges from 2,500 to 3,200 tons. Silver possesses a ratio of 22. Other metals like palladium and platinum have ratios of 1.1 and 0.4. Bitcoin provides a similar scarcity profile. The network produces approximately 328,500 BTC annually. Total mined Bitcoin stands at roughly 18.5 million coins. The total supply remains capped at 21 million. This fixed supply makes the stock-to-flow ratio highly predictable. The pseudonymous investor PlanB published a Medium article in March 2019 which used the stock-to-flow model to quantify Bitcoin scarcity through a comparison between its existing total supply and its annual production rate.
| Asset | Stock-to-Flow Ratio | Annual Production |
|---|---|---|
| Gold | 62 | 2,500-3,200 tons |
| Silver | 22 | N/A |
| Bitcoin | 56 | 328,500 BTC |
Demand and volatility influence the price
Demand influences price more than scarcity alone. A common myth suggests that the S2F model only accounts for Bitcoin’s market supply. This view ignores how growing demand drives value. Since 2019, Bitcoin has seen a massive influx of retail and institutional investors. This growth can cause the price to rise even when the supply remains constant. Regulatory changes also influence these dynamics. Stringent regulations in China can decrease demand. Furthermore, the introduction of Bitcoin ETFs has changed the way institutions access the asset. ETFs allow investors to gain exposure without holding actual coins. This creates a new demand structure through centralized custodians. The model also fails to account for Bitcoin’s utility beyond scarcity. Bitcoin’s supply is defined at the protocol level, which makes its flow predictable. However, the network difficulty adjusts every 2016 blocks to maintain consistent block times. Bitcoin mining difficulty changes impact the rate at which new coins enter the system.
Long-term trends show the model works
Long-term trends remain the most reliable aspect of the S2F model. Many traders believe the model is useless because it fails to predict short-term price volatility. However, the model tracks major bull cycles. PlanB predicted Bitcoin would reach $55,000 by the May 2020 halving. Bitcoin reached nearly $60,000 in 2021. In early 2022, the price fell 62% below the target. This deviation happened during macroeconomic tightening. Still, the model captures the macro movement. Does the model still hold weight after years of deviation? You should not rely on this model for daily trading decisions. The price of Bitcoin reached $56,113 in February 2021. In early 2022, Bitcoin traded at around $43,000. Recently, the price reclaimed the $70,000 level after a period of pressure. Vitalik Buterin argued that the theory is unfalsifiable because analysts attribute any price as evidence that the model is correct.
The S2FX model integrates multiple assets
The S2FX model incorporates multiple assets into a single formula. PlanB developed this cross-asset model to remove the time component. It uses gold and silver to validate the growth of Bitcoin. This model predicts Bitcoin market capitalization could reach $5.5 trillion. This translates to a price of $288,000. The S2FX model shows a significant relationship between the stock-to-flow ratio and market value for all six assets studied. It uses a regression analysis to make the S2FX model. The model identifies four clusters of Bitcoin value. These include the proof of concept, payments, e-gold, and financial asset phases. The model suggests that Bitcoin is currently in the financial asset phase. The S2F ratio for this phase reached 25.1 with a market value of $114 billion. The model uses silver and gold data to build a perfect straight line. This regression analysis provides a 99.7% R2.