Bitcoin News
Security and functionality failures of Chivo wallet adoption

Chivo users face persistent technical failures when attempting to use the state-backed wallet. The government provided a $30 Bitcoin incentive to every citizen who signed up for the app, a program that cost up to $75 million. President Nayib Bukele promised the application would save Salvadorans $400 million in annual remittance fees by bypassing high commission charges. However, many users report that the application fails to record shipments even when the system marks them as completed. Juan Carlos Rivera, a student, attempted to receive $500 from his brother in the United States, but the transaction vanished when he tried to use a Chivo ATM. Roberto Lopez, a bricklayer, reported that his daughter sent $300, but the application failed to load the shipment despite reporting it as completed. During the initial launch in October 2021, the system suffered from server saturation and was unavailable on certain Apple and Huawei devices. Bukele noted that the app was initially only available for specific versions of the Samsung Galaxy S20 and S21. These errors create significant financial risk for families who rely on remittances for daily living expenses. Although the government claimed the app reached 2.2 million users, 91% of Salvadorans preferred the US dollar over Bitcoin in 2021, and 71% of the population lacks a bank account. This digital divide persists because El Salvador holds the lowest ranking in the 2023 Broadband Development Index.
Chivo Adoption Specification
Detail
Bitcoin sign-on incentive
$30
Total incentive cost
$75 million
Bitcoin legal tender rescinded
February 2025
Users without bank accounts
71%
Salvadorans preferring USD
91%
A massive leak of personal information exposes millions of users to identity theft and fraud. The database, which reached a size of 144 GB, includes the full name, a unique identity number, date of birth, address, phone number, email address, and even a high-definition photo of each citizen involved. This information likely came from the registration requirements for the Chivo wallet. Since last August, criminals have been able to purchase this data to target Salvadoran citizens. The leaked data appears to come from a cloud backup of Alejandro Muyshondt, the former national security advisor. Because the government provided the $30 Bitcoin incentive to all registered citizens, hackers used these stolen identity numbers to open unauthorized Chivo wallets and claim the funds. This breach directly links the identity verification processes for Chivo to the exposure of over 5 million citizens. Experts suggest the data comes from the KYC registration processes used to verify users.
The government rescinded Bitcoin as legal tender in February 2025. This decision followed years of international pressure from the International Monetary Fund. The IMF warned that Bitcoin’s volatility threatened El Salvador’s financial stability and consumer protection. While President Bukele promoted the technology to improve remittances and financial inclusion, the experiment faced significant pushback. The government eventually agreed to limit its involvement with Bitcoin as part of an agreement with the IMF. The country moved to abolish the legal tender status to secure a $1.4 billion financial assistance program. This shift followed the 2021 decision to make Bitcoin legal tender, which the Legislative Assembly passed with a 62 to 84 vote. At that time, the government set aside $150 million in cash to back the country’s Bitcoin. In 2022, the value of Bitcoin fell by approximately 45%, which caused the national reserves to lose $22 million. The government continues to hold Bitcoin in its strategic reserve, which held at least 1,801 Bitcoins valued at $66 million as of January 2022. By March 2025, the reserve contained 6,102 coins valued at about $500 million.
Scammers target new Bitcoin users through sophisticated phishing and malware. Criminals create fake apps or browser extensions that mimic legitimate wallets to steal private keys. They also use "pig butchering" schemes, where they build trust over weeks before convincing a victim to invest money into a fake platform. This process involves building a relationship, securing early wins, escalating the investment, and then a final freeze where the scammer disappears. You should always verify the first and last characters of a recipient’s address to avoid malware that replaces addresses in your clipboard. Phishing scams also impersonate legitimate services to pressure users into signing permissions that drain their assets. Fraudulent investment platforms also promise high returns to lure users into depositing funds that the scammers then steal. Criminals also send microscopic amounts of Bitcoin, known as "dust", to a user’s address to facilitate reconnaissance or prepare for more complex attacks. This method includes address history poisoning, where the attacker sends dust from an address whose first and last characters match the recipient’s regular address. In 2024, scammers also used fake WalletConnect schemes to target users via email notifications. Additionally, Chinese hackers used fake Skype and WhatsApp apps to install malware that automatically replaced TRON or Ethereum addresses in messages with the attackers’ own addresses.